And The Mince Pie Bake Off Winner was … ?

Christmas Eve: 3.13 pm

The back door of the Sanctuary burst open. Ads exploded in, bringing with him a blast of icy air, the rattle of bags and the clumping of boxes. He deposited everything on the kitchen table then strolled curiously over to where I was inhabiting the Chef Area.

Ads (curiously): “What have you got THERE?”

He peered into my pan of rustic mandarin and apple diced mincemeat.

Me (guarded): “Mince-pie filler.”

Ads (crestfallen mixed with surprise): “What are those bits you’ve added?”

Me (poker faced but confidence perking up): “They are mandarin slices and diced up apple.” When I say diced up apple I mean very roughly chopped up chunks. Like I said – rustic.

Ads rummaged in a carrier bag and pulled out a sullen jar of 50p shop mince pie filling. “I could only get this horrible stuff. I didn’t have time to get anything ready. The deli was too busy.”

My confidence rocketed from perked up to gleeful.

“And I’ve literally only been able to bosh this up too. It’s Madagascan vanilla and nutmeg pastry with ground almonds.”

He took out a cling filmed lump of dough.


Confidence dipped.

Not only did Ads’ pastry dough have secret ingredients, but it was also very smooth looking. Not like the lump of gritty, buttery, pastel lemon stuff I had chilling in the fridge.

“And luckily, I had time to make this last minute …” Ads carefully extracted two tubs of beautiful dark brown mincemeat, gleaming with rich red cranberries and the fresh green of pistachios. “I added cognac and salt flakes too. That other jar was just in case …”

At this point my confidence hit rock bottom.

And had a tantrum.

“I knew it!” I cried, eyes narrowing and pointing accusingly. “You are a liar and a cheat! How could you make me think my mincemeat was GOOD and then you have made an even nicer one. WITH cognac. Which was my idea!” (I had gone out to buy cognac and come back with Cointreau because I’d become Bird/Baby Brained in the chaos of Sainsbury). ” And you have used a lovely mixing machine to mix your pastry whilst I had to use my hands and I don’t even KNOW how to rub the butter in!” Then I added, with hopeful triumph, “but LOOK. I have this!”

Whipped open the fridge and pulled out my hazelnut infused cream.

Ads smiled and his big eyes shone.

He pulled out a tub of homemade Christmas Pudding parfait. “And I have this.”

Then the bake off commenced.

6.00pm – Binnel Studios

The four judges are assembled around the table. They have each been blindfolded. There is a sense of heightened anticipation in the air.

The House of Bethan

Expectant hands hold spoons and await the serving of the first mince pie.

Sure enough, the first mince pie is served.

The House Of Bethan

Each mouthful is received and savoured with with serious consideration.

The House of BethanThe judges discover that there is an art to trying to eat a mince pie, whilst

a) unable to see the bowl

b) unable to know where to put one’s fork

c) to know where one’s mouth is and if one has accidentally picked up an  entire mince pie and whether it will even fit into one’s mouth

The House of Bethan

The second pie is then served.

Between sips of water and animated mince pie debate, many a compliment and incredibly diplomatic criticism is delivered.

The House of Bethan

It is a very hard moment.

A moment of painful, excruciating decision …

The House of Bethan

But finally the moment has arrived.

The House of Bethan

Everyone is feeling a bit sick. The House of BethanThe blindfolds are revealed … and the winner is announced!

A: “I thought number two definitely one. The pastry was lovely!”


P: “I thought that if this is a competition based on the best mince pie (emphasis on mince pie), number one would have to win. Mince pie two was more like a fruit tart. It was very nice, but not really like a mince pie.”

??????? Damn you rustic mandarin slices!

F: “This is really hard. They were both lovely. I feel so sick! I would have to say that the filling on mince pie one, but the pastry on mince pie two.”

…. Hmm …. this sounds like fence sitting to me …

M: “Yeah, I agree with F. Mince pie one for filling and two for pastry.”


Finally, once the judges had recovered from the eating of two mince pies whilst blindfolded, both mince pies were brought out and displayed in all of their glory.

This was the final part of the bake-off: the Presentation Round.

You can click on each image to see who won ….

The House of Bethan


2 thoughts on “And The Mince Pie Bake Off Winner was … ?

    • Haha, I’m glad you liked my presentation Debs. I kind of drop/squirted the bottle and created an interesting Wabi-Sabi effect. I think that it was a definite combination of Granny Balchin’s pastry cutters and the frozen butter that did it. Hope you had a fab time at M’s. xxx Oh – we just walked as far as we could along the Undercliff. There is a drill down there taller than the trees and these weird iron pegs that are 10 metres long that look as though they are going to be drilled into the road to stop it all collapsing! I reckon we’ll feel the vibrations!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s